Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

Edited by Arya Kumar, Samantha Ruenzi, Amelia Cantwell, and Owen Andrews

Since his 2016 election, President Donald Trump has drawn criticism and attacks from the left, denouncing him as a fascist. At first, leading scholars specializing in the field of fascism and authoritarianism, such as Robert Paxton, discouraged such labeling, asserting that the overuse of the word “fascist” diminishes the term to a mere curse word. However, as Trump’s recent rhetoric, behaviors, and actions have revealed, the term “fascist” is increasingly fitting of his persona and conduct. Although fascism is difficult to define and no two fascist regimes look the same, Italian scholar, semiotician, and literary critic Umberto Eco outlines 14 principles in his essay “Ur-Fascism” that help explain the complexities of this ideology. Eco, who experienced Mussolini’s fascist dictatorship firsthand as a child, famously articulated that fascism should not be understood as a concrete political ideology. Rather, it must be recognized as an amalgamation of sometimes contradictory political beliefs and values that manifest differently depending on a nation's environment and historical context. In examining Trump and his behaviors, whether that be through his increasing display of military force, obsession with creating grandiose “spectacles,” labeling of “disagreement as treason,” or the adoption of a cult of personality, he can be seen as following many of Eco’s principles as well as mirroring and imitating the behaviors and actions of historic fascist leaders such as Mussolini and, yes, even Hitler. 

One of the most striking examples of fascist behavior in Trump’s administration is his deployment of force in the domestic realm. To project and assert dominance, Trump has aggressively deployed countless National Guard members, ICE agents, and military personnel throughout various cities across the nation. In past presidencies, such force was used sparingly and in exigent circumstances. For example, in the past nine presidencies (excluding Trump’s first term), the deployment of troops to major US cities occurred only twice to combat extreme civil unrest. Trump, on the other hand, over the span of four months, authorized deployments to combat “civil unrest” in over five major US cities. Generally, these deployments took place in cities where most voters identified as Democrats, and more often than not, these deployments were called in against the wishes of state governors and local officials. However, Trump proceeded to execute such deployments all while publicizing and documenting the events on his social media as a way to not only promote a form of nationalistic and militaristic propaganda but also as a way to incite outrage from the left. Videos posted by both Trump and the Department of Homeland Security featured clips that glorified masked men dressed in black forcefully arresting alleged undocumented immigrants off the streets without citing a warrant for their arrest. In glorifying such unbridled use of militarized force, these videos serve as a form of political propaganda, transforming immigration enforcement operations into public spectacles imbued with a deep sense of machismo, national strength, and uncompromising authority. Thus, these videos reflect and reinforce an image of Trump—one that he is constantly promoting—in which he is portrayed as the nation’s ultimate strongman and protector. Furthermore, the videos’ portrayal of intimidation tactics eerily highlights the similarities between ICE’s paramilitary actions and those of Hitler’s SS Men or Mussolini’s Blackshirts, who violently detained, arrested, and elicited fear amongst civilians throughout their respective cities with little to no restrictions on the scope of their power.

Another aspect where Trump can be seen as deriving inspiration from fascist regimes is through his obsession with architectural spectacles, such as the Roman arch. Within the past year, Trump has become consumed by the idea of building a massive arch across from the Lincoln Memorial. The original plan for this monument featured a “250-foot-tall triumphal arch” decorated with two gold bald eagle statues, flanking a statue of a Lady Liberty-like figure. This arch strikingly mirrors those constructed in Fascist Italy, such as the Monumento alla Vittoria, a Roman-style arch commissioned under Mussolini in the city of Bolzano. It was built to honor Italy’s military victory in WWI and to assert fascist dominance over the newly annexed region of South Tyrol, which hosted a predominantly German-speaking community at the time. Moreover, the arch conveyed Italian national superiority, as it not only incorporated symbols linking Mussolini's regime to the glory days of the Roman Empire but was also used in political ceremonies, rallies, and military celebrations. Although triumphal arches are not inherently fascist symbols themselves, Mussolini’s usage of this architectural spectacle highlights how the Roman arch has been used to advance a cult of tradition, portray a deep sense of nationalism, and assert military dominance. In this way, Trump's desire to build a “triumphal arch” is significant and noteworthy, given that Roman arches stand as one of the most identifiable relics of fascist regimes, serving as physical manifestations of ultranationalism and a cult of tradition. 

Another example of Trump deriving inspiration from fascist buildings and monuments can be seen through the placement of colossal banners displaying his face on federal buildings such as the Departments of Justice, Labor, Agriculture, and the Interior. All of these banners similarly depict Trump’s face in a stern pose, mirroring banners and images of Mussolini’s face that were hung on government buildings throughout Fascist Italy. In this way, Trump evokes a cult of personality, likening himself to well-known authoritarian leaders such as Mussolini, who used such propaganda to project an all-encompassing, omniscient power and to remind the public that he, the supreme leader, was inseparable from the state and its institutions.

“Disagreement is treason” and Politics as war: Two of Eco’s leading claims about fascism are that, in order to thrive, fascist leaders and regimes must create a state of political warfare in which disagreement is considered treasonous. Trump, similar to Mussolini and Hitler, has created such an environment. Whether through his increasing attacks on the media and news outlets, his bullying tactics against political opponents, or his use of government agencies to investigate and prosecute his political enemies, Trump increasingly uses tactics to distinguish an “us” (his devout MAGA following) and a “them” (political opponents, critical journalists, public figures, immigrants, and others whom he views and portrays as a threat to his authority). 

One way in which Trump creates this political divide is by claiming that news outlets increasingly provide “fake” news. As of September 18th, Trump banned CNN, MS NOW, and Politico from covering the White House on the grounds that their coverage spews “FICTION, LIES, and FAKE NEWS.” On September 24, when a judge ruled that Trump could not ban the reporters and that their badges and privileges must be restored, Trump and his administration initially refused to comply. This not only highlights Trump’s creation of a vilified media but also his complete disregard for the Constitution and rule of law. Trump plays by his own rules as he bulldozes traditional limits of presidential power, and increasingly there appear to be little to no consequences or institutions capable of holding him accountable to the law.

Another way in which Trump can be seen as enforcing the idea of “disagreement as treason” is through his use of the DOJ to investigate and prosecute his political enemies. In 2025, the DOJ, following intense pressure from Trump, indicted two of Trump's political adversaries: Letitia James and James Comey. Letitia James, the Attorney General for NY who brought a $454 million civil fraud case against Trump, was charged with bank fraud for falsely describing a property she purchased, calling it a second home instead of an investment property. James Comey, who was the former FBI Director leading investigations into whether or not Russia was involved in Trump’s 2016 presidential campaign, was indicted on charges of obstructing Congressional proceedings and making false statements to Congress during a 2020 testimony to the Senate Judiciary Committee about Russian interference in the 2016 election. Furthermore, in April of 2026, Comey was charged again; however, this time on counts of knowingly and willfully threatening the president’s safety because he posted a picture to his Instagram in which seashells were arranged into the numbers “86 47,” which was interpreted as an alleged death threat. Although the charges against both James and Comey from 2025 were quickly dismissed in court, it shows how Trump, even with little to no grounds, is more than willing to use government resources and agencies to take down his political opponents.

Trump’s willingness to use government institutions to seek retribution against his political foes is further evidenced through his and the DOJ’s most recent and last-ditch attempts to charge Comey. On October 5th, just as the ten-year statute of limitations was set to expire, the DOJ filed a criminal information suit—an exceedingly rare charge typically used for misdemeanors carrying a sentence of 1.5 years or less, or when the defendant waives their right to a grand jury—against Comey for allegedly violating the Espionage Act by sharing classified information with the media. It is significant that the government filed a CI, as compared to a formal indictment, because a CI enables prosecutors to file charges against Comey without obtaining an indictment from a grand jury. Even though two different teams of prosecutors investigated this exact matter during Trump’s first administration and found insufficient grounds to charge Comey, Trump and the DOJ continue to reject the previous findings in order to build a case against and eventually arrest Comey. These highly unusual tactics illustrate how Trump has co-opted the DOJ to manipulate and contort the law by any means necessary to execute his personal vendettas against his political foes. This example, and recent failed efforts to indict Cassidy Hutchinson, a key witness against Trump in his second impeachment trial, highlight how Trump repeatedly uses the justice system not to uphold the rule of law but rather to punish political dissent.

Screenshot 2026-11-15 at 1.45.04 AM Screenshot 2026-11-15 at 1.45.44 AM

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c17v8y0z9z2o and https://arsof-history.org/articles/v4n2_creating_a_demigod_page_1.html

One of the most visceral instances of Trump’s fascistic behavior is when, in April of 2026, he posted an AI-generated image of himself as Jesus healing a sick individual to his Truth Social account. This image, which includes American flags, bald eagles, fighter jets, military personnel, government buildings and monuments, and hordes of bystanders reverently looking at Trump, serves as an all-encompassing image of fascist propaganda. It is striking how similar this image is to propaganda pieces created by regimes such as Mussolini’s Italy or Nazi Germany. In portraying himself as a “god,” Trump evokes a deep sense of Christian nationalism and draws attention to the fact that he sees himself as an “infallible” and “supreme” leader, both of which are crucial elements in a fascist regime. At the center of a fascist regime, there is a mythic and divinely worshiped leader who creates a cult personality surrounding themselves. In a democracy, however, there is no divinely appointed king. Yet, the leader of the supposed “free world’s” social media account implies otherwise. 

Something worth noting is that Trump doesn’t unilaterally fit the fascist ideology. Fascism, in one of its most basic definitions, is a far-right, ultranationalist political ideology that places the nation above all else, including the individual. However, Trump has never, and arguably will never, place the nation, or anyone, for that matter, above himself. His refusal to accept the results of the 2020 presidential election, even at the expense of his own vice president, Mike Pence’s, life and the democratic institutions he took an oath to uphold, exemplifies this distinction. Similarly, despite his repeated promises to restore law and order to our nation, Trump pardoned convicted individuals who violently defiled our nation’s Capitol and attacked our nation’s democracy and law enforcement officers on January 6. Such contradictory behaviors expose his hypocrisy. When convenient for him, Trump eagerly embraces nationalism and characteristics of fascist regimes that serve to benefit him, such as extreme militarism, a cult of personality, and suppression of political dissent. In this way, Trump differs from traditional fascist leaders as his devotion to the nation extends so far as it serves his own agenda, interests, and self-image. Hence, Trump is not devoted to a form of fascist ideology. Rather, he is driven by an insatiable desire for attention, validation, the spotlight, and power, which explains why his actions, words, and behaviors are extremely volatile and contradictory. 

Ultimately, it does not matter whether Trump can “technically” be labeled a fascist. What matters is that Trump is an existential threat to U.S. democratic institutions and values. Throughout his two terms, he has increasingly pushed the boundaries of his presidential power through his extensive use of executive orders (bypassing the co-equal legislative branch), his reshaping of the judicial branch, and his accelerating disregard for the rule of law. Rather than becoming fixated on whether or not Trump squarely fits the definition of a fascist, we should be more concerned with the shocking erosion of political institutions and norms that have enabled Trump to act in such anti-democratic ways. Although I do believe that the rule of law will prevail and that Trump will be unsuccessful if he tries to maneuver into a third term, who’s to say that one of his devout disciples and fascist sympathizers won’t take his place?

It is more important than ever that citizens educate themselves on what is happening in our government, critically examine politicians’ rhetoric and purported goals as compared to their actions, and consult credible, nonpartisan, and diverse news sources. Moreover, citizens must fulfill their civic duty by voting in local, state, and federal elections, as this simple action enables one to hold their elected officials accountable. While voting is essential to preserving democracy, it is not enough by itself. Preserving democracy further requires that citizens recognize and speak out against abuses of power, even when doing so could mean challenging a leader from their own political party. It requires compromise, open dialogue, and cooperation. Politicians and citizens alike cannot simply acquiesce to the erosion of democratic norms or accept a weakened version of the democracy our forefathers envisioned, fought for, and ultimately established. The United States has reached a fork in the road, and it is imperative that we commit to preserving its democratic institutions and values over our partisan loyalties.